
What the Trump, Xi and Putin summit signals to the world
11/19/2026 | 26m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
What the historic Trump, Xi and Putin summit signals to the world
President Trump meets with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin in an unprecedented show of three leaders who understand the power of grand diplomatic gestures. On a special edition of Compass Points, Nick Schifrin is in Shenzhen, China, and has details on the historic meeting and the message it's sending. Plus, Stephanie Sy analyzes the summit with Heather Conley, Patricia Kim and Charles Kupchan.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback

What the Trump, Xi and Putin summit signals to the world
11/19/2026 | 26m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
President Trump meets with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin in an unprecedented show of three leaders who understand the power of grand diplomatic gestures. On a special edition of Compass Points, Nick Schifrin is in Shenzhen, China, and has details on the historic meeting and the message it's sending. Plus, Stephanie Sy analyzes the summit with Heather Conley, Patricia Kim and Charles Kupchan.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Compass Points from PBS News
Compass Points from PBS News is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipIt’s the summit seen round the world.
Here in Shenzhen, China, President Trump meets with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin.
Tonight, a look at the historic meeting and the message it’s sending globally.
Coming up on a special "Compass Points."
♪ Announcer: Support for "Compass Points" has been provided by... the Judy and Peter Blum Kovler Foundation, Camilla and George Smith, the Dorney Koppel Foundation, the Gruber Family Foundation, and Cap and Margaret Anne Eschenroeder.
The Judy and Peter Blum Kovler Foundation.
Upholding freedom by strengthening democracies at home and abroad.
Additional support is provided by Friends of the News Hour.
♪ Announcer: This program was made possible by contributions to your PBS station from viewers like you.
Thank you.
Once again, from the David M. Rubenstein Studio at WETA in Washington, Here is "Compass Points," from PBS News.
Hello and welcome to "Compass Points."
I’m Stephanie Sy.
It was an unprecedented show of 3 leaders who understand the power of grand diplomatic gestures.
China’s Xi Jinping, who maintains an iron grip on power, warmly welcoming a U.S.
president whose foreign policies his own vice president suggested played a role in his party’s recent midterm losses.
And Russia’s Vladimir Putin, whose relationship with Xi and engagement with Trump has resisted many Western leaders attempts to isolate him.
Observing all of this firsthand, our Nick Schifrin, who joins us now from Shenzhen, China.
Nick, obviously a landmark photo opportunity.
But what did the leaders discuss and agree to during the trilateral meeting?
Stephanie, the leaders discussed lots of topics and they agreed to what they called a declaration toward peace.
They pledged to release more oil to try and reduce global gas prices.
They admonished the International Criminal Court that the U.S.
is trying to destroy as the court tries to arrest Vladimir Putin.
And they vowed to have future talks about, quote, "reducing nuclear risks "after China has resisted "those kinds of arms control talks for many years".
Now, in the end, Stephanie, Xi Jinping got what he wanted.
He convened the top two nuclear powers.
Vladimir Putin got a PR win on the world stage and no pressure from Trump or Xi when it comes to Ukraine.
And President Trump got few concrete deliverables, although his aides are telling me tonight that that arms control agreement that China has made to at least talk in the future is significant.
You know, Stephanie, the president has lived a lifetime of made for TV moments.
But this is going to be still one of his most indelible images.
Well, yeah, let’s talk about the images, Nick.
What might we glean from the exchanges that were captured on camera during the summit?
What do they say about these relationships?
They say that President Trump is very serious about maintaining very good relationships with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin.
Take a look at how Trump interacted with Putin in their bilateral.
They were chummy.
Putin was called "his friend" by Trump.
This is body language for old pals, not for rival powers.
And there was a seemingly small moment on an escalator where Xi was holding Trump’s arm.
Xi’s hand slips.
Trump reaches out to reconnect.
Now, you might consider this stuff stylistic rather than substantive.
But for the Chinese, how you treat Xi Jinping is a prerequisite for any cooperation.
And on the flip side, Trump’s messaging has Ukraine and the U.S.
’s traditional European allies deeply concerned.
The prime minister of Poland, Donald Tusk, said earlier that "Putin is not our friend, "nor will he ever be."
A senior European official told me that Trump called into a meeting of European leaders and said that Putin was ready for peace.
This official tells me that the leaders were astonished and do not agree with Donald Trump’s assessment.
And they are increasingly concerned that at least in the long run, they will have to support Ukraine on their own.
Our allies decide there are several simmering issues in the U.S.-China relationship.
Talk about where we’re at with some of those.
Well, Stephanie, as you know, the tensions remain, especially over the 3 T’s: trade, Taiwan and technology.
Let’s start with Taiwan first.
Chinese media reported that Xi Jinping told Donald Trump to, quote, "keep doing the right thing."
That’s a reference to the U.S.
indefinitely postponing any kind of arms sale to Taiwan.
On trade, there was no progress on a trade truce that is keeping U.S.
tariffs down and expires in January.
And on technology, the fallout of Jensen Huang’s departure is playing out very quickly this week.
The administration, Nvidia itself and the chips giant TSMC, all trying to restrict China’s access to high end chips that have been at the center of the A.I.
race.
Bottom line is that that could make China’s ability to catch up to the U.S.
more difficult.
But it could also make that trade truce more difficult to extend, Stephanie.
What else should we expect to follow this summit, Nick?
Well, I think what we need to be looking out for is, one, whether those arms control talks continue, how far they go.
And we should be watching about how the tensions over trade and technology play out.
Next month, President Trump will host the G20 at his hotel in Miami Doral.
Xi Jinping is scheduled to attend.
Will the two sides be able to extend that trade truce by then?
And will Vladimir Putin attend?
He has been invited, but it’s not confirmed yet.
Sy: Finally, Nick, I want to talk about where you stand.
I was in Shenzhen decades ago.
Then it was a special economic zone where China was really experimenting with opening to the global economy.
A lot has changed since then.
What have you seen this week that gives a sense of what the city stands for today?
Nick: Well, it’s a fascinating story, Stephanie, because as you know, the person who was behind some of those changes in Shenzhen was Xi Jinping’s father.
Back then, the city was a fishing village, and his vision was to encourage foreign companies to invest.
Today, the city has 18 million people.
It’s an economic superpower, China’s Silicon Valley, and it’s home to the very A.I.
and technology companies that are competing with American technology companies.
But the foreign companies, Stephanie, have all been shut out.
Xi Jinping has cut off all steps toward capitalism.
And those Chinese A.I.
and tech companies, they’re now state champions, backed by Beijing, in part for their loyalty to Xi Jinping and the Chinese Communist Party.
And so the city in many ways is a symbol for how Xi Jinping runs China.
And the city’s ascent shows just how determined China is to try and catch up, and in some cases overtake the United States.
Sy: Not a small amount of irony there.
Thank you so much for your terrific reporting there.
Nick Schifrin from Shenzhen, China.
And now for analysis of this summit, we’re joined here in the studio by Heather Conley, a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute.
Patricia Kim is a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution.
She’s also the author of the forthcoming book, "No Constraints, "China’s Global Quest for Partners and Influence."
And Charles Kupchan is a senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, a professor at Georgetown University.
And his new book is.
"Bringing Order to Anarchy, Governing the World to Come."
Thank you to our distinguished panelists.
I’m going to start, gentlemen, first, Charles.
And that’s because there are plenty of critics of this meeting.
And you wrote an article in Foreign Affairs defending this meeting as a good idea.
Do you still think so after everything you’ve seen this week and why or why not?
I do think that the meeting should have taken place.
I’m not particularly surprised that not much was accomplished.
But in my mind, the reason to have the meeting was the meeting.
It was the break to ice.
It was to have Donald Trump sit down and begin to pursue in a more sustained, programmatic way, a conversation across ideological and geopolitical dividing lines with the Russian president and the Chinese president.
This is a conversation that I think needs to happen.
And I give Trump credit for setting a precedent that others can build on.
What came out of it?
I don’t think we know yet.
Let’s wait and see.
As Nick was saying, will there be a sustained conversation on arms control?
Was there a conversation about ending the war in Iran that we don’t yet know about?
Not not much has been reported about the meeting.
So, again, I think that the most important thing was the conversation.
Let’s wait and see whether there are any real deliverables.
Heather and Patricia, what do you think of about this?
What struck me as maybe a surprising moment was hearing President Trump use the word "friends."
The White House issued a statement after the summit saying that the 3 leaders committed to maintaining strategic stability and international security.
But what does it say about U.S.
foreign policy that a Russian president, who was one of the most destabilizing forces in Europe since World War II, was not only welcomed to the table as a great power, but welcomed as a friend?
Well, I mean, Vladimir Putin wanted this meeting desperately, in fact, proposed this meeting.
President Trump was eager for it.
Xi Jinping was a little hesitant.
They don’t usually like to wing it like this.
And yet I think this was the capstone of a week from ASEAN to APEC that demonstrated, I think, China’s growing dominance, how it views its dominance of the international system.
You know, to Charles point, meetings are important, but you build up to them, you get deliverables.
The leaders, you know, this is why the Anchorage summit last year between President Putin and President Trump, nothing came out of that.
So you’re right.
We will see how this works forward.
But this is bringing President Putin continue out of isolationism.
It elevates him.
It’s sort of a G2 and a half if you want.
This is not a great power.
He’s trying to cling to that great power status with his relationship with China.
But the message it sends to our allies, the split screen here, our European allies are meeting in Berlin at the same time to in some ways counter this meeting in Shenzhen.
Patricia, I don’t know if you saw the moment of the family photo when very clearly she seems to kind of shuffle Putin aside so that in the family photo, at least at the summit, Putin is standing next to Xi’s wife, the first lady.
Do you think that was deliberate?
Do you think that Xi wanted to be careful of welcoming Putin fully into the fold?
Well, you know, I think you could say that that is also a position of honor to be positioned to the next to Xi Jinping’s wife.
The important point is that Xi Jinping was in the center, and President Trump was on one side, and Putin was on the other side.
And that is exactly the type of image that we saw from this unprecedented trilateral, where there was a circular table.
But again, President Xi was straight squarely in the middle facing the cameras, with Putin at that time to his right and Trump to his left.
And that’s what must be disconcerting for our allies and partners who have been worried about this prospect of a G2 or a G3 making decisions that middle powers or smaller powers don’t have a say over.
And if you look at the outcomes of the summit, it was pretty low on substance, high on symbolics.
There was the peace declaration that Nick talked about.
And in there, there was no mention about Ukraine or Iran.
There were sort of generalities put forth about pursuing peace.
There was a reference to pursuing nuclear dialogue, which is welcome.
But we’ll have to see where it goes from there.
You know, committing to a dialogue and actually having a dialogue that leads to substantive outcomes.
Those are two very different things.
Sy: Heather, Putin arrived in the region and made a bit of a show with nuclear bombers landing in Vietnam.
Talk about the significance of that.
And how much does that show this was a coup, the summit itself, for Mr.
Putin?
Yeah, I mean, I think, again, it’s a symbolic gesture of the Russians that are in a growing alignment with China.
They have continued to do naval and air exercises in the Western Pacific.
That particular bomber, as it was going to Vietnam, tested the air identification zone of our allied Japan.
We know the Japanese prime minister is under enormous economic pressure from China right now.
And Russia is adding its own military pressure and questions over some still disputed territory.
So this is a symbol, again, I think Putin’s position, exactly as Patricia said, it was to make sure that the world understands that he’s in alignment with China and will help China continue to exert pressure along the first island chain.
Charles, I want to go back to this point you made about that this meeting could break the ice and pave the way.
I want to play something that President Trump said in an interview with Fox News in China this week.
Let’s listen to that.
You know, all my life, I read you’d never want to have Russia and China team up.
I was like one on one in politics or in warfare.
They both like Trump.
Now, what happens after me, that I can’t tell you.
So, Charles, I guess my question is, did you see anything out of this summit, out of the warmth apparent between Xi, Trump and Putin that the next president could capitalize on?
Or is it more likely that whoever the next American president is is more hawkish on China and is not willing to appease Putin?
You know, to the degree that I have heartache about the meeting, it was the way that Trump treated Putin.
And that’s because, you know, Putin is an indicted war criminal and he’s continuing to bomb Ukraine every night.
I do think we have to talk to the Russians because this is a war that needs to end at the negotiating table.
But I would like to see Trump put a little bit more distance with Putin and stand up to him, not embrace him.
With Xi, you know, I think that that Trump is doing the right thing by investing in this relationship.
Xi went to the airport to meet Trump, in part because Trump went to the airport when she came here.
That works well because China is coming off this long period of humiliation.
They want to be treated as an equal.
I do think that, yeah, the next American president, whether a Democrat or Republican, will be more hawkish on Russia and China than Donald Trump, because almost every American is more hawkish than Donald Trump.
But I do think that the next American president can engage in this kind of diplomacy more easily because Trump has broken the ice.
One final comment.
I do think that Putin and Xi know that they’re not going to have a better American president for their interests, especially now that the Democrats have won the midterms.
And in that sense, they have a vested interest in trying to make progress in the next two years before Trump is gone.
Will that happen?
We don’t know.
Patricia, I wonder how you see this, and both of you can respond, because you can certainly see how Xi and Putin would have benefited from the Trump presidency.
How has the U.S.
benefited?
Kim: So I completely agree with Charles that Putin and Xi both have an interest in keeping up these close, warm ties with Trump.
It’s been beneficial for them.
You know, I think the U.S.
and China, where does the relationship go, especially after the midterms?
That’s a big question.
And Capitol Hill is getting ready to put a you know, to put more scrutiny on the Trump administration’s policies towards China.
There’s a lot of anger that Nvidia chips and other U.S.
technology may have been diverted to China against U.S.
laws.
And so China will be in the hot seat.
And so that’s why they have a big interest in sort of keeping this leader to leader engagement going, because they see Trump as the most favorable advocate for for warm U.S.-China ties.
And that’s been a win for them.
But where does the U.S.-China relationship go?
I mean, if you look at the outcomes of the elections and the American people, they care about affordability.
And there is sort of a warming perception of China among the American public, which is really interesting.
So it’ll be interesting to see where the candidates pick up in 2028 if they sort of tap into that.
And I think, you know, President Trump has received a lot of pushback for a lot of policies.
But on China, you know, it’s a little bit more nuanced than just "he’s been bad."
Sy: What do you think, Heather?
Conley: I think the thread between Charles and Patricia, both Putin and Xi Jinping believe Donald Trump is working in their interest, not America’s interest.
And I find this highly ironic from the president that has an "America first" mantra that it seems to be the policies are in their interest, not in America’s.
And I think, absolutely to Charles point, that the pomp and circumstance, the flyover, the embrace.
And as President Trump and again, he said it on his way to Manila at the beginning of this trip.
"He’s my friend."
That means they’re an ally.
It’s not a personal relationship.
It is our country’s relationship, our security, our economic interests.
That is what the American president represents.
And so this total confusion of the personal and the relationship, the flattery, these leaders both understand how to win this president over.
But I think the price of winning the president over is actually to work against America’s economic security interests.
So the president isn’t doing his job, which is to secure us.
When Russia gives intelligence to Iran to harm U.S.
men and women in the Middle East, that is he is not our friend.
We don’t pat him on the back.
We actually say, "You will never harm an American serviceman."
These are the types of messages that I think that these leaders are playing it well.
But President Trump has got to defend the United States.
There was a former State Department official who wrote in The New York Times this week, "Mr.
Trump will be making nice with opponents "who have daggers "drawn against our allies and partners."
Xi is sitting on a one-trillion-dollar exporting juggernaut 6 months behind AI frontier labs in the United States.
What do you all think about how to approach a situation in which Xi holds the leverage, right?
He holds the leverage when it comes to making the war in Iran end.
He supports Russia in the war in Ukraine.
Trump also wants to resolve that.
He said he resolved it on day one.
And yet Xi, besides being a convener, does not seem to be willing to want to play that great power diplomatic role of resolving conflict.
Will that change?
Kim: So I don’t see that changing.
I think Xi Jinping is probably very happy with the way, for instance, this trilateral turned out.
It’s exactly the type of role that China likes to play, where it gets to burnish its image as a global peacemaker.
But it doesn’t have to make any really concrete commitments to try to resolve the conflicts that you mentioned.
Or it’s put in an uncomfortable place where it needs to pressure the Russians or the North Koreans, you know, for instance, or the Iranians.
They like to play this sort of symbolic global leader role without taking on real responsibilities.
I mean, that’s something that I talk about in my forthcoming book in terms of, you know, where does this go from from now?
I think the Chinese are going to continue to engage with the Trump administration, continue to say that they’re willing to talk about issues like nuclear risk reduction, not arms control, but nuclear risk reduction, addressing risks in A.I.
and these sort of these common interest problems that President Trump and President Xi have talked about.
But, you know, the question is, will there be really much substance to that?
And I think as both countries sort of double down on competing with each other and have an interest in sort of putting on more export controls and maintaining technological advantage when it comes to A.I., there’s going to be little political bandwidth or willingness to really talk about these issues concretely and to have concrete agreements.
There was so much talk about this being sort of a new Yalta, even though the circumstances are so obviously different.
The concern really being that, you know, these 3 men were going to carve up the world into spheres of influence.
I mean, now that the summit is behind us, what do you all think of those parallels and those anxieties that accompanied this summit?
Conley: Well, I think for me, there was less anxiety about the carve up.
I mean, the image is dramatic.
There are 4 points of U.N.
reform, and they were against the International Criminal Court and other issues.
But for me, and I think.
Patricia’s comments absolutely right, for me, the enduring image is.
Xi Jinping at the center.
And one of the comments that came before or after the trilateral meeting, he said, "The 3 of us look at Russia "for our China’s resources, "we look at America as this market."
I think it’s just a triumphal week of China saying, "Our governance, "our security, our initiative, this is our moment."
And I think this is why he sort of created this image.
I thought it would be much more of this, of the Roosevelt, that historic image from Yalta.
But I actually think it became much more of China as the center, and the world revolving around that.
Sy: Charles, do you think that the U.S.
is ceding too much influence to China?
Yes and no, right?
On the one hand, by basically turning his back on allies, by throwing Vladimir Zelenskyy out of the Oval Office and cutting off the flow of military and economic assistance, he seems to be pulling the United States out of the game and allowing China to kind of step in to the vacuum.
And that’s one of the reasons that everyone was saying, "Yalta, Yalta, Yalta."
And, you know, I think it was overdone because it’s not as if Trump can make a decision about Ukraine over the heads of Ukraine and then force it down their throats.
They have to say yes or no.
But one of the things that I do think Trump is trying to do, and I give him credit for this is bending the way we think about the U.S.-China relationship, because historically it’s been zero sum.
China is the existential threat, and we must win.
Trump, I think, is trying to say, "You know what?
"Maybe we need "to learn to work with China, to live with China, "but they haven’t actually been able to deliver."
And that’s I think what we have to wait and see whether Trump can do.
Sy: We’ll have to leave it there.
Heather Conley, Patricia Kim and Charles Kupchan, thank you so much for joining the program.
And thank you at home for joining us.
I’m Stephanie Sy.
"Compass Points" will be back next week.
Announcer: Support for "Compass Points" has been provided by... the Judy and Peter Blum Kovler Foundation, Camilla and George Smith, the Dorney Koppel Foundation, the Gruber Family Foundation, and Cap and Margaret Anne Eschenroeder.
The Judy and Peter Blum Kovler Foundation.
Upholding freedom by strengthening democracies at home and abroad.
Additional support is provided by Friends of the News Hour.
♪ Announcer: This program was made possible by contributions to your PBS station from viewers like you.
Thank you.
You’re watching PBS.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Today's top journalists discuss Washington's current political events and public affairs.


New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode


New Episode
Support for PBS provided by: